The one rule
A sailing club should not shop by construction material. For sailing dinghies the variables that decide whether the boat actually gets sailed are the local class fleet, club support, the class association, availability of replacement sails, masts, spars and foils, trailers and trolleys, the second-hand market, the training pathway, age and weight suitability and the racing pathway.
A perfect boat with no fleet within 300 km is a garage ornament. Sail what your club sails.
What to check before buying
- Which classes does the local club actually race on a Saturday? Ask for last season's results, not the website.
- Is the sailor inside the class weight range, and will they still be in twelve months?
- For class racing, does the boat have official measurement documentation? For an Optimist, the Australian association strongly advises obtaining and retaining it.
- What do sails, spars and foils cost, and who supplies them in Australia?
- What did the last three boats of this class sell for second-hand?
The pathway question
For clubs and families, a pathway matters more than any single boat. RS offers an unusually complete one under a single supplier — junior trainer to youth double-hander to adult trainer to performance dinghy — which simplifies parts and fleet management enormously. The ILCA offers a different kind of pathway: one hull, three rigs, a global class and reliable resale.